Weather Morning: 9°c Sunny spells Afternoon: 10°c Sunny spells

News

Treat literature savagely - and it will flourish

Sam Leith
24 Aug 2009


There are times when one has no choice but to stand back and admire.

This is what I am currently doing to Sebastian Faulks: standing back and admiring ... in the same way, and from the same distance, you might stand back and admire the unexploded doodlebug you have just dug out of your rosebed.

Mr Faulks has just given an interview in which - alongside some mildly astringent remarks about the stylistic shortcomings of the Koran - he makes clear that he thinks book reviewers aren't necessarily the best thing about the literary world. Look out!

Worse than that, his new novel, A Week in December, contains a book reviewer called R Tranter, whose sole delight is torching the reputations of writers whose superior talent and success he envies.

Some people think it is modelled on the Norwich-based literary anchorite DJ Taylor.

The explanations given for Mr Faulks's alleged antipathy to "the Deej" are various. Some say it's because he claimed that Sebastian once failed to get a job on the NME.

Others say that they were friends until he wrote a "devastating" review of Faulks's novel Human Traces.

Neither seems to me too convincing. Mr Faulks is in his right mind, mostly, so wouldn't make once not getting a job on the NME the basis for a vendetta.

And the review of Human Traces, while a bit sniffy, was far from a hatchet job. (Crocodile Dundee moment: "Hatchet? That's not a hatchet. THIS... is a hatchet!") Besides, in my experience curly-haired numpty Mr Faulks takes teasing with rather good grace.

He, anyway, says Tranter is not Taylor, and we are bound to believe him. If we're honest, a reviewer seething with envy and thwarted ambition could be any one of them - sorry, us.

The character of Tranter, says our Faulks, is intended to make a wider point.

The interview attributes to him the view that "British novelists cannot deliver the serious novel about their times in a climate of mockery".

It's a properly interesting question, this, and I don't think it's a closed one.

Those of us whose job it is to do the mocking tend to take the view - with unthinking self-assurance, it should be said - that a climate of mockery is good for serious literature.

We imagine serious literature as being like certain sorts of grapevine that do best in flinty soil, or roses that flourish when savagely pruned back.

There is no real evidence for this. But, likewise, there is no evidence - how could there be? - that great novels are suffocating in utero because their authors are scared of getting an unkind review from D J Taylor.

Either way, the one person who has surely now been finessed into giving Sebastian's new book a generous review is the Deej. No fool, that Faulks.

A sign of our rubbish times

It is an experience all too familiar to many Londoners.

In the small hours of the morning you hear vulpine howls, a scrabbling noise at the bottom of the garden, then the sound of the bins clattering over and bin-bags being torn to shreds.

"Oh God, darling. We've got bloody investigative journalists again ..."

Environment secretary Hilary Benn is the latest victim, caught red-handed with "glass, plastic, cardboard, paper and food" in his black bin bags when they should have been in the recycling bin.

I don't pass judgment one way or the other. But it feels like a sign of the smallness of our times. Ten years ago the notorious Benji "the Binman" Pell was selling newspapers scoops based on the contents of documents he found in people's rubbish.

Now the scoop is the fact the documents are in the rubbish at all, never mind what's written on them.

Look, would you buy a book from this woman

Tony and Cherie Blair are photographed this week in Beijing promoting the Chinese-language edition of Mrs Blair's autobiography Speaking For Myself.

They look very happy but it makes me wonder whether they might not both have gone a bit mad.

Would you walk into Waterstone's and buy a copy of Liu Yongqing's autobiography? Of course you wouldn't. You probably haven't even heard of Liu Yongqing.

I had to look on Wikipedia to discover the name of Hu Jintao's wife - and I imagine that for those Chinese people with access to Wikipedia the situation will be pretty much the same in reverse.

It may be objected that Cherie Booth is a relatively senior lawyer in her own right. But there's a rather limited market for memoirs of our legal system over here, let alone in other countries.

Mrs Blair's hardback was the 68,535th best-selling book on Amazon.co.uk yesterday. Her paperback was up at 15,499th.

If she betters their success with a push into the Chinese market, it'll be testament to how much more outward-looking the Chinese are than the Brits, and a credit to Mrs Blair's business acumen. But, like I say, I think she's gone a bit mad.

• On being introduced to a goateed designer at a Buckingham Palace party, Prince Philip is reported to have exclaimed: "Well, you didn't design your beard too well, did you?"

That's rather witty for off-the-cuff, I think. We're forever reporting the Duke of Edinburgh's "gaffes", as if he's some great dim lunk of a fellow with his foot constantly plunging into his mouth.

I think it's about time we acknowledged that the opposite is true.

The Duke's not being obnoxious by accident: he's being obnoxious on purpose. Which as we all know is the mark of a gentleman.

Reader views (0)

 Add your view

No comments have so far been submitted.


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • Riot axeman terror at McDonald's Axe man A rioter who terrorised diners with an axe at McDonald's has been jailed for five years and three months - one of the toughest sentences for...
  • Terror of boy exposed as gang witness Scotland Yard A BOY and his family had to flee their London home after a blunder by the Met and Crown Prosecution Service gave his name to gang members he...
  • MPs to visit Falklands for military inspection HMS Dauntless MPs are to visit the Falklands amid heightened tension between Britain and Argentina
  • Make 'death trap' junctions safer for cyclists, demands university mourning three Ellie Carey A university that saw two students and a member of staff killed cycling in London last year has accused Boris Johnson of failing to act...
  • Soho 'field hospital' for drunks reopens David Cameron smile A field hospital set up to deal with London's drunks is being extended as the binge-drinking crisis deepens in the capital
  • Jobless total jumps by 48,000 with UK facing 'zig-zag year' Job Centre unemployment Bank of England Governor Sir Mervyn King warned Britain faces a "zig-zag" year of growth and gloom today as unemployment rose by 48,000
  • Greens and Ukip could test Paddick in fight for mayor poll third place Paddick Brian Paddick could struggle even to finish third in this year's mayoral election, as smaller parties look set to capitalise on Lib-Dem woes...
  • Phone-hack private eye can appeal over human rights ruling Glenn Mulcaire The private investigator at the centre of the phone hacking scandal was today granted the right by the Supreme Court to appeal against a...
  • Google TV challenges Apple and Sky Google TV Google and Sony have joined forces in a bid to bring the internet to millions of televisions.
  • We're the Cockney rhyming gang: Poetry coaching given to Tower Hamlets pupils Bonner Primary School Hundreds of schoolchildren who had never been inside a theatre have been coached to write and perform their own poetry on stage
  •  

    Don't Miss
    • London Gateway

      Supersize superport: London Gateway

      London Gateway, the £1.5bn container port under construction on the Thames at Thurrock, will have capacity to unload six of the world's largest ships at one time and have as much impact on the capital as a new airport or half a dozen Westfield shopping centres
    • Matthew Williamson

      One stylish affair: Matthew Williamson

      With London Fashion Week kicking off on Friday, British designer Matthew Williamson tells Rosamund Urwin about breaking up with his ex, post-show partying and his new model man