Weather Morning: 9°c Sunny spells Afternoon: 10°c Sunny spells

News

The free-for-all must end: bring the web to heel

Jones
28 Aug 2009


Hello, you psychotic, whoring skanks!

Ah, that doesn't work, does it? Not with my name printed at the top of this piece.

But if this was an anonymous blog I could have said anything I liked about your morals, sexual preferences or attractiveness.

And all behind a veil of anonymity that shielded me from physical and legal repercussions.

Why? Because the web is still a Wild West.

It is largely unpoliced and riddled with error and malice.

A vicious, defamatory culture is rife among high-profile bloggers and in the reader comment sections on newspaper sites.

Schoolchildren do their bullying online as well as in the playground.

And Wikipedia entries about people (you know: real, living, sensitive human beings) are regularly vandalised.

It is also insanely uneconomic. Piracy has become widespread.

Consumers expect to pay nothing for valuable commodities such as news, music, film, television programmes, computer software and encyclopaedic information.

Newspapers wince as paying customers migrate to the web, reading the same - or better and more up-to-date - news and comment without paying a penny.

But the tide is turning. When Google recently complied with a court order to reveal the identity of a blogger (the author of "Skanks in New York") who really did think it was OK to call a model a "psychotic, whoring skank", we saw the beginning of an important paradigm shift in the online world.

All around, things are tightening up. The Man is taking the power back.

Wikipedia announced this week that articles about living people will now be formally edited. Not only will GCSE coursework become more accurate (Henry VIII apparently did not marry Catherine Tate), it also means that you can't libel someone just because you feel like it.

News freeloading, too, is facing an uncertain future.

Many people have ridiculed Rupert Murdoch's decision to move his news websites behind paywalls.

But soon this will look entirely sensible. Murdoch commands a bloc of newspapers and television stations.

Move them all behind the same, or linked, paywalls (buy Sky broadband, get the Sun for free?) and a big portion of the game is changed. It will take a tough newspaper proprietor to commit to free news if Murdoch is proved correct.

Pirates, too, are under attack. Under new government proposals, ripping off music and movies could cost your average geek his virtual lifeline.

The biggest punishment a nerd can face is the disruption of his broadband connection. (Mere hours without pornography and Facebook Scrabble have been known to cause breathing difficulties.)

The message? If you want it, pay for it. Unjustified attack on the ethos of the web, or a long-overdue overhaul of the online free-for-all? I say the latter.

If you disagree, you can slate me directly at www.summerofblood.com. (No paywall, yet.) Let the defamation begin.

Best keep Wat Tyler well away from these peasants

Here's an exercise in (un)historical imagination. It is June 1381. You are Wat Tyler, leading a ragtag army of villagers from Kent and Essex on a righteous crusade of justice against corrupt government, punitive taxation and social injustice.

You are on the way to Blackheath, where you intend to set up camp. But on the way there, you step through a wormhole in the fabric of space-time and end up in August 2009.

When you arrive at your destination, you are startled to find that the whole place has been taken over by a load of Hampstead hippies, with foldaway Brompton bicycles, buck-teeth and deferred places to study PPE at Oxford.

Several of them are strumming guitars and a working group is pitching a wigwam, using the camp-building skills they picked up doing their Duke of Edinburgh bronze award.

Tell me seriously that you do not feel your hand tighten around the handle of your pitchfork.

Freddie's sober triumph

I am always suspicious when sports stories move to the front pages of a newspaper.

Unless England have won (or, more likely, been woefully eliminated from) some prestigious international competition, it generally means that nefarious deeds must have taken place.

I'm thinking of drinking, whoring, speeding, cheating, fighting, betting, roasting and so on.

This week football and rugby have both been up front, thanks respectively to the baleful reappearance of British hooliganism and the continuing pantomime known as "Bloodgate".

Cricket is the only sport there for the right reasons: England beat a rubbish Aussie side to sneak the Ashes.

Hurrah! Freddie Flintoff deserves another trip to Buck House for remaining sober enough in his retirement celebrations to avoid English sport suffering a blanket disgrace.

Senator Ted Kennedy's death opens his life for assessment.

He is mourned by many Americans as a stately figure who transcended party politics in the name of liberal reform.

But his reputation is stained for just as many others by his fondness for living dangerously, symbolised most fatally by the Chappaquiddick accident in 1969.

How do we account for a man's private life in assessing his public legacy?

Generations of historians have scratched their heads over this question (and its inverse: how do we judge the Good Man who is a Bad King?).

The answer fluctuates with historiographical trends.

The easiest way to slip the question is to state that labels of "good" and "bad" are unhelpful in history.

But I can't help feeling that's an undergraduate's answer.

Human beings are essentially moral creatures, and to dismiss the difficult questions about right and wrong as oversimplifications is intellectual cowardice.

Reader views (0)

 Add your view

No comments have so far been submitted.


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • Riot axeman terror at McDonald's Axe man A rioter who terrorised diners with an axe at McDonald's has been jailed for five years and three months - one of the toughest sentences for...
  • Terror of boy exposed as gang witness Scotland Yard A BOY and his family had to flee their London home after a blunder by the Met and Crown Prosecution Service gave his name to gang members he...
  • MPs to visit Falklands for military inspection HMS Dauntless MPs are to visit the Falklands amid heightened tension between Britain and Argentina
  • Make 'death trap' junctions safer for cyclists, demands university mourning three Ellie Carey A university that saw two students and a member of staff killed cycling in London last year has accused Boris Johnson of failing to act...
  • Soho 'field hospital' for drunks reopens David Cameron smile A field hospital set up to deal with London's drunks is being extended as the binge-drinking crisis deepens in the capital
  • Jobless total jumps by 48,000 with UK facing 'zig-zag year' Job Centre unemployment Bank of England Governor Sir Mervyn King warned Britain faces a "zig-zag" year of growth and gloom today as unemployment rose by 48,000
  • Greens and Ukip could test Paddick in fight for mayor poll third place Paddick Brian Paddick could struggle even to finish third in this year's mayoral election, as smaller parties look set to capitalise on Lib-Dem woes...
  • Phone-hack private eye can appeal over human rights ruling Glenn Mulcaire The private investigator at the centre of the phone hacking scandal was today granted the right by the Supreme Court to appeal against a...
  • Google TV challenges Apple and Sky Google TV Google and Sony have joined forces in a bid to bring the internet to millions of televisions.
  • We're the Cockney rhyming gang: Poetry coaching given to Tower Hamlets pupils Bonner Primary School Hundreds of schoolchildren who had never been inside a theatre have been coached to write and perform their own poetry on stage
  •  

    Don't Miss
    • London Gateway

      Supersize superport: London Gateway

      London Gateway, the £1.5bn container port under construction on the Thames at Thurrock, will have capacity to unload six of the world's largest ships at one time and have as much impact on the capital as a new airport or half a dozen Westfield shopping centres
    • Matthew Williamson

      One stylish affair: Matthew Williamson

      With London Fashion Week kicking off on Friday, British designer Matthew Williamson tells Rosamund Urwin about breaking up with his ex, post-show partying and his new model man