Weather Tonight: 4°c Partly Cloudy Night Morning: 8°c Cloudy

News

Evening Standard comment

Prince Charles is right on teaching history

Evening Standard comment
19 Nov 2009


One of the subjects that the Prince of Wales feels most passionately about is education.

And in our interview today with Bernice McCabe, the co-director of the Prince's Teaching Institute, it is clear that Prince Charles believes strongly that traditional subjects on the primary school curriculum, notably history and geography, should not be done away with.

These are to be replaced with six broad-based areas of learning under reforms due to be implemented in 2011.

Mrs McCabe says that the Prince would be unwilling to criticise the Government openly. But through her, he has made his views known and they are trenchant.

On this matter, at least, Prince Charles's concerns are well founded. There is much that is good in the reforms proposed in the spring and accepted by Ed Balls, the Children's Secretary.

On the positive side, they give teachers greater autonomy about what to teach and place a premium on children being able to speak clearly.

But the proposals to do away with the old subject divisions and to replace them with the new areas of understanding, including "historical, geographical and social understanding" are likely to mean that children will leave school knowing less of substance than they do now.

There is everything to be said for collaboration across subjects, but if history is taught as a distinct subject, with a specified body of knowledge that children must learn, preferably chronologically rather than thematically, it provides pupils with something substantial.

A more diffuse, interdisciplinary approach would not have the same result. Mrs McCabe says the Prince "is passionate that these subjects should remain in the curriculum".

Most parents and teachers feel just the same. Children do not need new subjects; the old ones make sense - they just need to be taught coherently and well.

The speech, a day on

It has not taken much time for the criticism of the Government's legislative programme in the Queen's speech to come under attack.

Disconcertingly for Gordon Brown, some criticism is from his own side. Lord Lipsey, a care expert, and Lord Warner, a former health minister, have criticised the bill to provide free at-home care for the most vulnerable elderly, saying that the measure has not been properly costed and thought through.

The Tories say that to pay for the measure, it would be necessary for pensioners to lose their disability allowance.

Meanwhile, Sir Christopher Kelly has criticised the absence of any legislation to put into effect his proposals for reforming MPs' pay and privileges.

This is less fair; the central reforms can be implemented without new laws. What matters is that MPs back the spirit of the measures.

As for the Government's measures to reduce youth unemployment, it is made possible because not all the Treasury's funds put aside for joblessness have been used.

But the proposed work and training scheme also looks like a way to ensure that the figure for young jobless does not reach a million before the next election.

What is more, a day's reflection does not make the bill to oblige the Government to halve the budget deficit in four years look any more sensible. It should be doing that anyway; the question is, will it be with higher taxes?

Don't do it

The Tube unions have issued notices for four strike ballots and they may follow with a fifth. What this could mean in practice is a strike over the festive season.

Let's hear it from passengers first: don't do it. Please.

Reader views (0)

 Add your view

No comments have so far been submitted.


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • Riot axeman terror at McDonald's Axe man A rioter who terrorised diners with an axe at McDonald's has been jailed for five years and three months - one of the toughest sentences for...
  • Terror of boy exposed as gang witness Scotland Yard A boy and his family had to flee their London home after a blunder by the Met and Crown Prosecution Service gave his name to gang members he...
  • Mayor of poverty-hit council hires adviser in £1,000-a-day deal Lutfur Rahman Winterbottom One of the poorest boroughs in London is under fire for spending £1,000 a day on a personal aide for its mayor
  • Hyde Park mega-concerts at risk after neighbours complain about the noise Hyde park crowd Major music concerts in Hyde Park could be axed because Westminster council believes they are too noisy
  • Soho 'field hospital' for drunks reopens David Cameron smile A field hospital set up to deal with London's drunks is being extended as the binge-drinking crisis deepens in the capital
  • Jobless total jumps by 48,000 with UK facing 'zig-zag year' Job Centre unemployment Bank of England Governor Sir Mervyn King warned Britain faces a "zig-zag" year of growth and gloom today as unemployment rose by 48,000
  • Greens and Ukip could test Paddick in fight for mayor poll third place Paddick Brian Paddick could struggle even to finish third in this year's mayoral election, as smaller parties look set to capitalise on Lib-Dem woes...
  • Phone-hack private eye can appeal over human rights ruling Glenn Mulcaire The private investigator at the centre of the phone hacking scandal was today granted the right by the Supreme Court to appeal against a...
  • Britain's athletes could be banned from 2012 for criticising the team Olympic site British athletes risk being banned from the Olympics if they criticise team-mates or sponsors under rules that cover tattoos, contact lenses...
  • Teenager who dreamt of being a judge stabbed 24 times in 45 seconds Three thugs are facing life sentences for stabbing a teenager who had dreams of being a judge 24 times in 45 seconds in front of horrified bus passengers
  •  

    Don't Miss
    • London Gateway

      Supersize superport: London Gateway

      London Gateway, the £1.5bn container port under construction on the Thames at Thurrock, will have capacity to unload six of the world's largest ships at one time and have as much impact on the capital as a new airport or half a dozen Westfield shopping centres
    • Matthew Williamson

      One stylish affair: Matthew Williamson

      With London Fashion Week kicking off on Friday, British designer Matthew Williamson tells Rosamund Urwin about breaking up with his ex, post-show partying and his new model man