Fatima Bhutto: Why I'm a public enemy in Pakistan
Fatima Bhutto1 Jun 2010
Fourteen years ago, on the street where my family and I live in Karachi - on Clifton Road - seven men were murdered. The banyan trees provided sniper cover for the Karachi police. The street lights were shut. The roads were cordoned off.
More than 100 policemen had stood waiting for my father, Mir Murtaza Bhutto, their guns loaded and their orders undeniable. I was 14 years old, my brother Zulfikar six years old, when our father was murdered on the streets outside our home.
My father, an elected member of parliament and a strong critic of the government of his elder sister, Benazir Bhutto - infamous for its corruption, human rights abuses, support for the nascent Taliban in neighbouring Afghanistan and inept leadership - was shot several times. But he was killed with a point blank execution shot to his jaw.
My father and the six other men, all party workers who accompanied him that night as he returned home from a rally in the suburbs of Karachi, were left to bleed on leafy and expansive Clifton Road, a road that faced the British High Commission, the Italian consulate and other high-profile diplomatic enclaves. They died outside the beautifully decorated Clifton Gardens.
My aunt Benazir's government, in power at the time that her younger brother was murdered, stopped our family from filing a police report, a right we had to have returned to us by the Sindh High Courts. Her government arrested all the survivors and witnesses - keeping them in jail for the remainder of her term without access to lawyers, their families, or to us.
The police officers who had carried out the killings were internally cleared in a police review and put back on their beats. All promoted, to this day they remain powerful members of the Pakistani government and of police forces across the country.
Since Benazir's father, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, Pakistan's first democratically elected head of state, had been overthrown and killed by a military coup in the late 1970s, my aunt had presided over a fractured family dynasty. Her youngest brother, Shahnawaz, was killed in mysterious circumstances in France in 1985. A year later Benazir entered into power-sharing negotiations with the military junta that had killed her father, jailed her and her mother, exiled her brothers and - she believed - had ordered Shahnawaz's killing, in order to take her place in the dirty pantheon of Pakistani politics.
For 14 years my family and I fought for justice in the Pakistani courts, and six years ago I set out to fulfil the last promise I made to my father, hours before he was killed outside our home, that I would tell his story.
I was in the middle of studying for my Masters degree here in London, at the School of Oriental and African Studies, and I was 22 years old. I began the process of writing Songs of Blood and Sword and looking into my family's often tragic and violent histories by cold calling strangers. "Hello, you don't know me, but..."
I travelled across Pakistan to the northern frontiers of the country and across the southern shores of Sindh. I flew to London and Massachusetts and across Europe seeking out lost acquaintances and old lovers.
In 2007 my aunt Benazir was killed in Rawalpindi. In the aftermath, the streets were immediately cleaned up by the authorities, as they were after my father's murder. No police report was filed by the government led by her widower, Asif Zardari, and no criminal cases were launched against her assassins. I hadn't seen or spoken to my aunt for 10 years before her death and the questions I asked of her government's role in my father's murder went unanswered. Meanwhile the Zardari family keeps my grandmother - my father's mother - incommunicado in Dubai. We have not been able to see or speak to her for the past 13 years.
Two months ago, I launched my book in Karachi. That was the last time I was in my home, my city by the sea. To say that I expected outrage, writing as I had about the current Pakistani government's corruption, criminal past and increasingly worrying present, is to put it lightly.
What I didn't expect was the Pakistani establishment's decision to go nuclear. As I sit in London now, on the third leg of my book tour, politics in Pakistan seems ever so personal. Sulking family members, a lugubrious lot who benefited richly from the power and corruption of my aunt's two terms in office and now her husband's, came out of the woodwork.
The men who spoke to me of the violence they suffered under the state have been harassed and threatened. And I, flatteringly, have been turned into a public enemy of sorts. The years of research, pages of footnotes, interviews conducted over continents, and archive material sourced from libraries across Pakistan and Europe are no match for a hysterical state that has a dynastic reputation to protect and has powerful benefactors to answer to, who squirm when faced with the woeful tales of their billions of dollars of Pakistani aid money being squandered.
A fun fact: Pakistan is a nuclear-armed country that recently missed its millennium goals to eradicate polio. Not because we don't have the knowledge, but because we could not secure the constant refrigeration of the vaccines. Pakistan is a nuclear country that cannot provide electricity to its people.
The storm, exciting though it may be, around my book and me is ultimately not important. Persecution is a part of the Pakistani political ethos. What is worrying, however, is the direction of the feckless and autocratic regime of President Zardari, a man who once boasted to the British press that his government was hard at work fighting terrorism from al Qaeda to Aung San Suu Kyi, though no one seemed to have told the president that Miss Suu Kyi is a Burmese democratic campaigner and not an East Asian terror outfit. Details, mere details.
In the past two weeks, the state has banned access to Facebook, YouTube, Wikipedia and another 500 (or is it 1,000?) websites ostensibly because there is anti-Islamic material on those sites. Omar Zahid, a senior Pakistani television producer, has been raising alarm bells - falling on surprisingly deaf Western ears - reminding those who would excuse the Pakistani government's blanket censorship that "exchange of information has become a very powerful force in Pakistan".
Eric Schmidt, Google's CEO, said: "I'm always suspicious of these broad bans. In every case we looked at, there is an official reason, then another reason. There is an awful lot of political criticism they are blocking at the same time. I am very suspicious here."
Meanwhile, business carries on as usual. On May 18 President Zardari pardoned his unelected interior minister, Rehman Malik, who had been convicted of corruption in 2004.
In the Frontier province, a seventh-grade student, Natasha, the daughter of a poor local stone crusher, was held by police officers and raped for 21 days. After bravely filing police reports, Natasha's family has yet to see a single one of her accused rapists discharged from the police force or brought to justice.
No10 Downing Street and the White House have kept shtum on both cases.
What, then, is the difference between the "democratic" regime of Asif Zardari - who, like the dictator Pervez Musharraf, disdained national elections and was chosen by his own parliament - and the burgeoning Pakistani Taliban? Both oppose freedom of expression, both use Islam to rally people around their oppressive causes, both would ignore the rights of women - under this government, a woman may still be stoned to death for adultery. Who needs the Taliban?
This is the state that Britain and the US support, financially and politically, as the only option to keep Pakistan's Islamists at bay. Perhaps it's time for a new argument to justify this indefensible support of Pakistan's regime? Or not.
FATIMA BHUTTO
Born: Kabul, Afghanistan, May 1982.
Age: 28.
Status: Single. Might adopt children.
Education: American school in Karachi; degree in Middle Eastern Studies at Columbia, New York; MA at London's School of Oriental and African Studies.
Lives: Bhutto family home in Karachi with Lebanese stepmother, Ghinwa, adopted six-year-old brother and 19-year-old half brother Zulfikar.
CV: Campaigning journalist.
Family history: No contact with her Afghan mother, Fowzier. Her father, Mir Murtaza Bhutto, shot dead in Karachi, 1996. In 1985, her uncle, Shahnawaz Bhutto, was poisoned in France. Fatima and her cousin, Sassi, found the body. Fatima's grandfather, Zulfikar Ali Bhutto, fourth president of Pakistan, executed in 1979. Estranged aunt and president of Pakistan, Benazir Bhutto, assassinated in 2007.
Fatima Bhutto talks to Aminatta Forna at the Hay Festival on Bank Holiday Monday at 10am.
Reader views (9)
Kudos to Fatima for speaking out against the corruption in Pakistan. That takes a lot of courage, especially since the method to silence such critics is well known in authoritarian governments. I hope she continues her work and remains safe while doing so.
And to those who criticize her for not joining politics, it is purely a personal decision. She is doing her job as a concerned citizen and a journalist by talking about the issues within Pakistani government, but apart from that we cannot expect her to become a politician just because she's a Bhutto or she's politically active. There are other ways to serve society, and she's doing a damn good job at it.
- Armaan, New Delhi, India, 21/04/2011 04:47
Report abuse
Brave you are! Best Wishes Always
- Sindhyar Khan Palijo, Karachi, 31/05/2010 23:45
Report abuse
First of all, kudos for your book. Second, it is bit harsh. Your father was no saint. Infact, he betrayed Tipu. Had he not betrayed Tipu, he would have never got killed and there would have been no Taliban and there would have been no Benazir bhutto.
The death of Tipu sealed the death of Pakistan and no matter how many genocides Pakistan keep on committing, it's fall is inevitable and whoever who support pakistan in this game will fall as well.
- theirghteous, Pune, India, 30/05/2010 21:06
Report abuse
How surprising that this article - subject to my comments being published - has resulted in only 4 permitted responses. It must have elicited far more, but perhaps they were not sufficiently PC?!
That successive Pakistani governments have been devious hotbeds of corruption for decades is a fact well known to the West and to seriously believe that the present government has any intention of eradicating the taliban, or using nuclear power for anything other than weaponry development is a pipe dream, General McCrystal! The country is a bad egg in every sense of the epithet and not to be trusted as an alleged "ally"
- David Boyle, Cairns, Australia, 30/05/2010 17:27
Report abuse
Well done, Fatima, I can see light of future in you. Keep up.
- Pritam Jaipal, Birmingham, UK, 29/05/2010 14:59
Report abuse
Good on you Fatima. I'm glad someone's telling the truth.
- Safraz Sheikh, London, UK, 29/05/2010 03:19
Report abuse
Bless you Fatima, for a great piece, and for always speaking out.
I think however, that comparing Asif Ali Ghadari (as John McCain once put it) to Musharraf is a little unfair. Fair enough neither were elected by the masses, but the latter had some principles at least. For a start he was the man responsible for freeing up the press; it was under him that independent News channels popped up left right and center. What we now have, on the other hand, is a glorified bank robber.
- Saff, London, 29/05/2010 03:15
Report abuse
Ms. Bhutto is indeed a strong character to face up to the corrupt regime that is in Pakistan.
But i must ask, whether Ms.Bhutto has any intentions to join this corrupt system, because all indications are pointing so. If not, then as a public figure, who has the utmost respect by the literate youth of pakistan, she should come and accuse the people she wants to. making veiled suggestions isnt going to help her or her cause.
i agree with her criticism of Pakistan's internal system, its politics and policies, its taking us into a black hole of no return, where i am sad to say, Pakistan is heading towards an Iraq like situation in the next ten years. unless, something drastic happens, like a political revolution, new faces, new leadership and a brand new beauracratic system, run by thorough professionals rather than well wishers of a sitting govt.
i do not think Ms. Bhutto's late father's case will ever be solved, neither will her Aunt's. for that is the way of the shadowy governments, running the country from behind the scenes. therefore, i implore on Ms. Bhutto, to invoke a sense of responsibility within the youth of pakistan....that is her best chance of getting justice in the future.
- Faisal Shah, Karachi, Pakistan, 28/05/2010 18:11
Report abuse
Pakistan is not run by politicians anymore, it's run by gangsters. I have huge amounts of respect for Fatima for speaking out and addressing the tribalism/barbarism in Pakistani politics, she is putting herself on the line selflessly and that is indeed honorable.
A few months ago I was watching a Pakistani debate program on which PPP Federal minister Sardar Abdul Qayyum Khan said: "We have a right to corruption" - just google it, he was blatantly admitting to it live on TV.
The PPP has been stripping people of their rights to free expression and individuality. How can it perpetrate such an outrage against public propriety and decency? Well, while you're deliberating over that, let me ask you another question: To what degree is it going to create a one-world government, stripped of nationalistic boundaries, that is obedient to its agenda? Now, not to bombard you with too many questions, but if we take its ravings to their "logical conclusion", we see that before you know it, it will do away with intellectual honesty.
To sum up the current situation in Pakistan: Brainwashing by the government, brainwashing statements made to us by politicians, entertainers, and sports stars, and brainwashing by the news media. Let me end this by challenging Pakistani readers to build a true community of spirit and purpose based on mutual respect and caring.
- Saleem Cheema, Leeds - England, 28/05/2010 12:42
Report abuse
Afternoon:
15°c

















