Weather Morning: 14°c Cloudy Afternoon: 15°c Cloudy

News

MPs who play the glamour game tend to come unstuck

Anne McElvoy
4 Jan 2012


She's very odd, Louise Mensch. Sharp, gifted, uncommonly pretty and prone to putting her elegantly shod foot in it. Having graced Tatler magazine, she has now moved on to a GQ poster shoot, attired like a sexed-up Holly Golightly in leather-fronted skirt, while complaining that discussion about her appearance had "obscured" her political statements.

Nothing is dafter than MPs playing the glamour game and then complaining about not being taken seriously. Should they be smartly dressed? Of course: this is a job that means representing the public and we can expect to be aggrieved if they turn up on TV in gardening jeans.

Ed Miliband just sounds pitiful saying he would rather wear big glasses and nasty jumpers than the dapper suit leadership demands. If Mr Miliband favours such a look, he could stay where many feel he belongs: in Left-liberal academia. But if he wants to win in a competitive arena where impressions count and presence is important, he will have to put away his inner anorak.

At the same time, it is always a road to career ruin to mistake brash exposure with impact.

Theresa May's truly awful shoes did get a lot of coverage. But Ms May has also confounded critics who thought she was lightweight by hanging on to a difficult job without too many clangers. In her good-humoured but straightforward demeanour, she is a good advertisement for women in high places.

Ms Mensch, au contraire, is making the same error as Labour's Caroline Flint, the Don Valley diva. Ms Flint once appeared in a photoshoot swaddled in orange silk, which is a good look for Strictly contestants but not wannabe ministers.

The other problem with taking the Sarah Palin route and mistaking fame with good political fortune is that it leads you, like Ms Mensch, to beg publicly for promotion, despite having only just been elected. Not much of her concern comes through for her constituents, only for her career.

"What do I have to do to get promoted over here?" she says. "Am I being disloyal?" (No, just annoying.) And finally: "I need to sit down with my whip and say, 'What do I have to do?'"

Oh, where to start? By dropping the lofty tone of presumption, perhaps? Or by waiting until Mr Cameron actually holds a reshuffle? So far, he has promoted only a couple of women ahead of many very able young men from the 2010 intake. Ms Mensch's complaint seems to be that it is not her.

She did herself no favours by leaving a session cross-questioning James Murdoch at lunchtime on a key date for her committee, citing the need to pick her children up from school. Women who want to play big roles in public life cannot at the same time grandstand about their home priorities.

I recently sat down to dinner with a bunch of the new Tory intake of women. They were fun, hard-working, well turned-out and more varied than you might suppose. Many were state school-educated and had come from unglossy backgrounds. I was struck by their utter seriousness about what they do, and left hoping that Mr Cameron changes the face of his ministerial team by giving them a real shout at power. But they won't get there by mistaking attention-seeking for competence. And neither should they.

Reader views (0)

 Add your view

No comments have so far been submitted.


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

 

  • RBS posts £2bn loss for 2011 RBS Taxpayer-backed Royal Bank of Scotland remained at the heart of the row over bankers' pay today as it unveiled total losses of £2 billion...
  • MP Eric Joyce suspended after arrest over Commons bar brawl Eric Joyce Labour MP Eric Joyce has been suspended from the party following allegations of an assault in a House of Commons bar last night
  • GPs 'overpaid for ghost patients' GP waiting room GPs have been over-paid millions of pounds for patients who have moved practice, died or been forced to leave the country, according to a...
  • Parish vicar faces jail for carrying out 250 sham weddings for illegal immigrants Shipsides A parish vicar who conducted at least 250 sham marriages to help illegal immigrants stay in the country is facing jail
  • UK degree courses slashed by a quarter, says study Oxford University The number of degree courses on offer at UK universities has been slashed by more than a quarter in the past six years, new research...
  • Tube staff abused over misleading service updates, says union Tube HQ Tube staff are suffering assaults and verbal abuse because London Underground regularly misleads commuters over the state of the service,...
  • Comedian Frank Carson, 85, dies after losing cancer battle Carson Tributes have been paid to comedian Frank Carson, best known for his catchphrase "It's a cracker", who died at the age of 85
  • 'This poor man's Shard will cast a blight on our homes' Fake shard A new 35-storey skyscraper will loom over west London like a "weak rip-off of the Shard" claim neighbours who vow to fight the plan
  • Give us an Uggie! How canine star of The Artist has found homes for rescued terriers Uggie Jack Russell The canine star of Oscar-nominated film The Artist has spurred an unprecedented surge in demand for rescued Jack Russells
  • January mortgage approvals rise to two-year high First-time buyers UK mortgage approvals rose in January to the highest in two years as buyers tried to complete purchases before a property tax suspension...
  •  

    Don't Miss