Weather Morning: 9°c Sunny spells Afternoon: 10°c Sunny spells

Theatre

A Matter of Life and Death was panned by the critics
A Matter of Life and Death was panned by the critics
A Matter of Life and Death was panned by the critics Nicholas Hytner has accused male critics of chauvinism Emma Rice and her Kneehigh theatre company adapted the classic Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger film

Now theatre critics are panned

Louise Jury, Evening Standard
14 May 2007


The head of the National Theatre has launched an astonishing attack on critics as "dead white men".

Nicholas Hytner, the theatre's artistic director, accuses the veteran reviewers of the national press of being effectively biased against female directors.

Hytner said they could not help but notice a director's gender. They would also "snigger" at lesbian directors who were not accepted in the way that gay men, like himself, were.

He tells The Times: "They would be horrified by the accusation, but I'm afraid I'm making it.

"I think it's fair enough to say that too many of the theatre critics are dead white men. They don't know it's happened to them but it has."

The attack follows some of the worst reviews the National has received in years for the adaptation by Emma Rice and her Kneehigh theatre company of the classic film A Matter of Life and Death.

Nicholas de Jongh of the Evening Standard awarded it just one star out of five. Few of his fellow daily - male - reviewers were much kinder. Yet the Sunday newspapers, which employ more women, were more positive. Susannah Clapp, of The Observer, described it as "a phenomenal achievement".

Hytner, 50, said that many of the critics of the national press are men who were already in their jobs when he was at university - Michael Billington has reviewed for The Guardian since 1971 - and he suggests that is an influence on their reaction to what they see on the stage.

He said: "I won't stay in my job for as long as they stay in theirs. When I become a dead white male I will only be hired to do dead white male theatre."

Some critics could not help but notice that a play was directed by a woman, he said. "The theatre establishment changes regularly and representatively because the audience changes. We have to change or the audience would stop coming."

Hytner added: "I think it's a very good thing that at least on Sunday there's a female voice or two amongst the theatre critics."

Theatre directing is one area of employment where women have made many advances in recent years. Although there are still fewer women than men, directors such as Phyllida Lloyd, Thea Sharrock and National regular Katie Mitchell are acknowledged big hitters.

But Hytner said: "I know that Mitchell gets misogynistic reviews where everything they say is predicated on her sex."

The critics responded angrily to the claims. Billington said they were "balderdash and piffle".

He said: "It seems to me to be ageism. We are not dead, whatever else we are, and the idea that critics review productions on the basis of gender and sexual orientation is absolute nonsense."

Benedict Nightingale, of The Times, who turns 68 today, accuses Hytner of being "an ageist bigot".

Of the 12 current and forthcoming shows at the National, five are directed by women. Other plays currently being directed by women include Mamma Mia, Equus and Happy Days.

Thea Sharrock, 30, who directed Equus, said: "It's really changed during the last 10 years or so. I think it's a much healthier balance now."

Reader views (4)

 Add your view

Girls, boys, leprechorns, eunuchs...all that matters is that enchanted theatre...and new writing must prevail... 'The Dreamers Of Inishdara,' opens at the Jermyn St today.

- Debbie Bourne, LONDON, UK, 26/11/2008 07:54
Report abuse

Hytner's just doing what happens in Cornwall after any criticism of a mediocre Kneehigh production. If you don't appreciate their facile capering you must be a very nasty person and you should keep your opinions to yourself.

- Pauline Liu-Devereux, Hayle, UK, 21/05/2007 10:48
Report abuse

Attacking the critics when your show is total rubbish is a very old ploy which fortunately never works.

- Jon Tee, darien, USA, 14/05/2007 18:37
Report abuse

Sometimes I think some reviewer's' idea of a perfect West End is a West End full of empty theatres.

- Hnm, London, 14/05/2007 18:13
Report abuse


Add your comment

 

Terms and conditions Make text area bigger You have  characters left.

We welcome your opinions. This is a public forum. Libellous and abusive comments are not allowed. Please read our House Rules.

For information about privacy and cookies please read our Privacy Policy.


 

Theatre top five
Matilda The Musical
Matilda: The Musical

Cambridge Theatre

Earlham Street, WC2H 9HU

Rating: 5 out of 5
The Comedy Of Errors

National Theatre

SE1 9PX

Rating: 4 out of 5
Hamlet

Young Vic

The Cut, SE1 8LZ

Rating: 4 out of 5
The Ladykillers

Gielgud Theatre

Shaftesbury Avenue, W1D 6AR

Rating: 4 out of 5
Noises Off

Old Vic

The Cut, SE1 8NB

Rating: 4 out of 5